Sunday May 31, 2020
SNc Channels:



Feb-18-2014 13:26printcomments

Solutions for a Broken Mental Health System

The focus for every provider needs to be on diagnostic accuracy, and this will only come by increased training in mental health care within the entire medical establishment.

Mental health

(DURHAM NC) - The mental health system in America is in terrible shape, and unless something is done to fix the problem it’s going to get a lot worse. School shootings, gunmen in malls, “suicide by cop,” and other violent acts continue to dominate the headlines and the news cycle with no end in sight.

The problems are many, with a severe shortage of mental health care professionals and inpatient facilities, combined with the continual decline of insurance reimbursement rates and increasing bureaucratic hurdles leading more than half of psychiatric providers to stop accepting insurance.

This creates an even greater lack of resources – especially for those patients in socioeconomic groups who are not able to pay out of pocket. These patients typically see non-psychiatric physicians, nurse practitioners, physician assistants and other extended care providers, who handle more than 90% of psychiatric care in the U.S., yet only receive six to 12 weeks of training in psychiatry over their entire medical school and training careers.

All this leads to misdiagnosis and underdiagnoses of mental health conditions. For example, studies have estimated that only 20% of patients with bipolar disorder are correctly diagnosed. In a third of bipolar patients, it takes an average of 10 years to get the correct diagnosis.

The Solutions

The focus for every provider needs to be on diagnostic accuracy, and this will only come by increased training in mental health care within the entire medical establishment. Training through MOOCs (massive open online courses) is becoming more widely accepted as a means of continuing medical education. These online courses give physicians access to the best teachers in the country.

A similar and very simple solution is more online medical education resources that provide timely, unbiased, evidence-based medical education and information from renowned medical experts, researchers and clinicians in the field available on-the-go on all digital devices.

We need to make sure there is more emphasis on the detection and treatment of psychiatric illnesses in the early stages. The sooner a patient receives the correct diagnosis, and the quicker treatment is initiated, the better the outcome. Screening for common psychiatric illnesses like mood and anxiety disorders in primary care practices should be part of the initial differential diagnosis, along with other medical illnesses, rather than an afterthought like it currently is for patients who do not respond to medical treatments or in whom the myriad of unnecessary tests are negative.

Too many patients are bounced around the system until they receive a proper diagnosis. Educating non-psychiatric providers to be extra vigilant in patients who suffer from depression, anxiety or substance abuse, or who have red flags for certain conditions is one such way to ensure a proper diagnosis the first time. These simple messages presented to every clinician can markedly improve diagnostic accuracy.

We need to reprioritize the payment structure of the new insurance policies. Reimbursement for psychiatric care should be commensurate with higher reimbursements for providing evidence based care. There should be no expectation that dwindling payments will produce better results.

We need to reorganize and strengthen the infrastructure of the mental health field. We need more inpatient psychiatric beds so that the mentally ill are not housed in jails or the streets. The government needs to stop subsidizing organizations and advocacy groups that “help” the mentally ill refuse treatment. The standard for inpatient commitment should be broader than the “imminent danger to self and others” standard. Involuntary outpatient commitment laws like Kendra’s law need to be adopted nationwide.

Mental health is the key to our overall health. As a society, we are more aware than ever that staying mentally fit is just as important as maintaining our physical health. Yet, overall, the mental healthcare field has been neglected, which is unacceptable. The costs involved in maintaining the resources needed to support an adequate system are insignificant when compared to the dividends that will be returned to us in productivity, safety, and a better quality of life.


Dr. Prakash Masand is a former consulting professor of psychiatry and behavioral sciences at Duke University Medical Center and is CEO of Global Medical Education



Comments Leave a comment on this story.

All comments and messages are approved by people and self promotional links or unacceptable comments are denied.

Night Visions February 18, 2014 7:38 pm (Pacific time)

Dr Prakash Masand M.D. while I agree that improper diagnosis and inadequate training behind diagnosis is a problem, it is not simply the nurses and doctors who have little training, it is the very people treating those with mental illness. a 1 year certificate social worker, at any random community college, can take the role of counselor for someone. I personally was seeing a 1 year social worker intern (there were to permanent staff ever available, all I had access to was interns). This intern stated that he thought I had a certain mental illness. I said, well, lets discuss the DSM criterion that you and your people are using to decide that diagnosis, the intern stopped talking. I recently went into an appointment at this same mental health care center in Salem OR. On the top of the sheet that lists my medication was a DSM code. returning home, I found I had been listed as having dementia normally attributed to lifelong alchoholics who were elderly. I'm not elderly, I don't have dementia, and I have no symptoms of what qualifies for a diagnosis of this DSM code. there is no oversight over the random diagnosis being thrown out. I have requested an Adendum to my mental health records and have been completely ignored. There is no outside agency that sits down with me and my mental health providers. there is no accountability. if you call for greater power for doctors and prescribing individuals to force medications on people, then you are completely messed it in this picture and I wish you would retire. I am educated and these people who have a major role in my legal and medical life? they are incompetent and only rewarded for handling clients like me in bulk. Oregon is in the bottom of the barrel. be careful of what you wish for those at the top of the barrel, because it will affect us as well. wishing for more beds in institutions? Out here in Oregon, federal oversight has found that Oregon relies much to heavily on institutionalization. almost criminally. what happened to group homes? community based group homes where the "Customers" of the care have a home and then go to a center, where they can choose to either stay, or go out into the community on an outing? what the heck is wrong with pursuing that? it's less expensive than institutionalization. and it's better than forcing developmentally disabled of people with mental disabilities to get a crap job doing menial labor. where is this country going?

[Return to Top]
©2020 All opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of

Articles for February 17, 2014 | Articles for February 18, 2014 | Articles for February 19, 2014
Tribute to Palestine and to the incredible courage, determination and struggle of the Palestinian People. ~Dom Martin

The NAACP of the Willamette Valley

Special Section: Truth telling news about marijuana related issues and events.


Donate to and help us keep the news flowing! Thank you.